Johnston & Murphy vs Allen Edmonds: Crack the Constant Clash of Shoes

Suppose a grand event is ahead, and you need a pair of dress shoes to go with your classy attire. However, you are stuck with the puzzle: Johnston And Murphy vs Allen Edmonds. Which brand to choose in the battle? Indeed, a complicated condition.

In my opinion, Allen Edmonds is better than Johnston And Murphy. Though they both make good leather dress shoes, Allen Edmonds comes with premium quality and promising features. Despite being a little expensive, its maximum comfort, diverse styles, and durability make them a worthy choice.

To find out which brand comes out on top in these categories, check out our dissection of Allen Edmonds vs. Johnston and Murphy.

Johnston And Murphy Vs Allen Edmonds: Comparisons 

TopicsJohnston And MurphyAllen Edmonds
ComfortComfortableMore comfortable than Johnston And Murphy
StyleStylishComes with more variations and style.
DurabilityModerately DurableVery Durable
QualityStandard qualityPremium Quality
CostsCheaper than Allen EdmondsExpensive

When it comes to quality shoes, both Johnston and Murphy and Allen Edmonds are top-shelf shoes. However, it’s good to know every detail about them for a decision. So, let’s start.

1. Comfort

Johnston And Murphy Vs Allen Edmonds

The higher the quality of a shoe, the more likely it is to have better-cushioning materials to comfort your feet longer through all-day work. They will last longer and help keep your feet from getting sore or injured. Yes, they are pricy but think how much money you spend on a doctor every time your feet hurt.

Now, if you are looking for ways to save money while still buying quality footwear, look into Johnston & Murphy. It would be cheaper to buy it and save yourself the trouble. These brands will give you great value without sacrificing style or comfort. However, they may not provide quality quite like an Allen Edmonds.

On the other hand, if you want to spend money on your shoes and care about quality, Allen Edmonds might be right. Allen Edmonds has been around since 1922, so they know what they are doing when it comes to making high-quality shoes. 

Their products reflect their experience and expertise in craftsmanship. With such a long history behind them, you know that you’re getting something special when buying Allen Edmonds. Although they are a bit pricey, you will get what you pay.

2. Styles

Allen Edmonds and Johnston & Murphy: both brands make classic leather dress shoes lasting years. But which company will you choose when buying your first pair of stylish shoes?

Allen Edmonds offers around forty different oxford shoe styles, while Johnston & Murphy offers many more styles – from lace-up boots to slip-on shoes to chukka boots.

Each brand has dozens of different color options for its footwear, whether two-tone shades or solids like black or brown. 

The range available at each brand is impressive, if not overwhelming, for a new shopper looking for their first pair of quality footwear.

3. Durability

Both Allen Edmonds and Johnston & Murphy are renowned for their superior craftsmanship, handmade and stylish leather shoes built to last longer. 

However, Allen Edmonds is a clear winner when it comes to durability. 

With a company history of over 100 years, it’s no surprise that their shoe offerings boast quality construction, with full-grain leather uppers hand-stained in rich colors that wear like iron.

On top of that, they also have an extensive selection of styles, including oxfords, loafers, boots, and more. Plus, you can be sure your Allen Edmonds will be around for decades to come, and you can pass them down from generation to generation! 

On the other hand, Johnston & Murphy shoes are also well made, although not as durable as Allen Edmonds. For example, their leathers aren’t full-grain (instead of being top-grain or corrected), which means they won’t last quite as long-especially if you wear them every day. And when it comes to style options, they have fewer to choose from than Allen Edmonds-and many of their styles seem a bit dated compared to AE’s offerings. 

4. Quality

With Goodyear built, Allen Edmonds’ quality in men’s shoes is superior to all others. Their craftsmanship is unmatched, as evidenced by their lengthy menswear history. 

The vast majority of Allen Edmond shoes are made in America and can be resolved by them indefinitely. These details provide a shoe you can wear for years to come and certainly beat out Johnston & Murphy any day of the week.

On top of that, they’re made with high-quality leather-like Horween Chromexcel or suede. Depending on your choice, they even offer full-grain leathers that range from beautiful to stunning. 

Even if you don’t choose Allen Edmonds for every style, I’d highly recommend every man have a pair or two in his collection instead of lesser brands like Johnston & Murphy. It is an easy one, folks.

5. Costs

Price can make or break a purchase decision, and it’s hard to say which company has better prices overall. Allen Edmonds shoes are generally more expensive than Johnstons and Murphys.

As you can see, Allen Edmond shoes can last up to 5 years, while Johnston & Murphy shoes last about a year or two.

Shoes by Allen Edmonds range in price from $200-$500, while Johnstons & Murphys range between $95-$300. Allen Edmond shoes can also last longer than Johnston & Murphys.

Besides that, Allen Edmonds makes some of its men’s dress shoes in Italy, where labor costs are higher than in China (where most other brands make their shoes). 

Therefore, it’s understandable why Allen Edmonds’ Italian-made shoes will cost you around $400 per pair, and Johnston & Murphy’s shoes cost about $250 per pair. 

On the flip side, you can get Johnston & Murphy’s less expensive non-US dress shoes for as little as $150 per pair. 

Other factors come into play when comparing these two companies’ prices. Allen Edmonds is often available at sale prices, so if you’re willing to wait for a sale, you might be able to save money by buying from them. 

Which Brand Is Best For You?

Which Brand Is Best For You

It would be easy enough to declare either Allen Edmonds or Johnston & Murphy as the winner based on style and price alone, but many more factors are involved in choosing one brand over another. 

Ultimately, we think that style, quality, comfort, durability, and price are all important factors in deciding between these two companies, but other things matter too.

Both Johnston & Murphy and Allen Edmonds are known for their fine shoes. However, they stand out in a variety of different ways. There’s no question that Johnston & Murphy is a top name in men’s footwear, but its offerings tend to skew more toward conservative looks.

On the other hand, Allen Edmonds has a much wider selection of styles, including dressy shoes as well as designs that are better suited for casual wear. 

The choice between these two companies comes down to your own personal style. If you want something more classic, Johnston & Murphy might be right. 

If you’re looking for something with a little more flair, then Allen Edmonds might be a better fit. Either way, you can’t go wrong with either company.

Additionally, if you’re willing to pay extra for high-quality shoes, Allen Edmonds is probably your best bet. However, if you are willing to save money, Johnston & Murphy’s prices make them an attractive option.

Here is a list of a few Johnston and Murphys and Allen Edmonds shoes to add to your dresser, considering your preference.

Is Johnston and Murphy a luxury brand?

Is Johnston and Murphy a luxury brand

Obviously, Johnston and Murphy is a luxury brand.

For years, Johnston & Murphy has been a leading provider of men’s dress shoes. Since 1850, their fine-quality footwear has been recognized for its reliability in both quality and style. 

Nowadays, however, J & M offers several different products, ranging from clothing to accessories. This wide range of goods has caused some confusion over whether or not J & M still operates as a luxury brand that produces only shoes. 

Although many other items are available through J & M, they have maintained their reputation as one of America’s premier shoe brands. They continue to provide high-quality leather dress shoes for customers around the world. 

The company upholds its reputation by using only top-quality materials when creating each shoe. They are also known for their durability, quality craftsmanship, and attention to detail in their products.

It is clear that J&M has continued its tradition of providing quality footwear for many years now and will continue doing so in years to come. 

However, it is important to note that even though J&M has expanded into other areas of business, including clothing, accessories, etc. 

So, while J & M certainly offers many different items beyond just shoes, they have maintained their position as one of America’s premier luxury shoemakers.


  • Does Johnston and Murphy use real leather?

Yes, Johnston and Murphy use real leather in many of their products. The shoes are made with the finest materials available and include genuine leather.

  • Who makes Johnston Murphy shoes?

“Made in the USA” is stamped on every pair of shoes made by Johnston & Murphy. It doesn’t matter if you buy J & M shoes from a retailer or directly from their website; most of their shoes are proudly manufactured here in America.

  • Are Allen Edmonds sneakers good?

Allen Edmonds is known for making some of America’s finest dress shoes. But can Allen Edmonds make a decent pair of sneakers too? Yes, they sure can. In fact, I think their sneakers are better than most other brands on the market today for their durability and comfort.

  • Does Johnston and Murphy use Goodyear Welt?

In the early days of Johnston and Murphy, they used Goodyear Welt on almost every product lineup. But today, they only use it for their “Aristocrat” products.

Final Thoughts

Are you still scratching your head assessing Johnston and Murphy Vs Allen Edmonds?

The quality of these two brands is very similar. Both companies have their pros and cons, but it comes down to personal preference. 

If you’re looking for stylish, comfortable, high-quality dress shoes, you should go with Allen Edmonds. 

However, if you’re looking for a cheaper alternative that is still stylish, then Johnstons & Murphys will be your best bet.

Leave a Comment